Thanks NomadLawyer - I don't know PR super well (I've actually never been to Vieques), so I do welcome any advice! Right now we are in the stage of making a list of places we should visit over the next few years. PR isn't as scary to me, since I do have some experience there. I love how much the island has to offer in terms of nature, adventure, and culture. It's so diverse! I'm sure that the perfect location doesn't exist, but I've got plenty of time to look! I'm hoping to find a place that has a small town feel (no condos, strip malls, etc). I grew up on the beach in FL, but there were always big waves, and I don't surf - that's why we are focusing our search on the Caribbean ;-) I want somewhere that has great snorkeling and sea life. My favorite places to travel to have always been low-key tourist spots (no resorts in sight), and could always imagine myself being part of that type of community (catering to tourists who appreciate the local feel)... Anyway, like I said, I know the perfect place probably doesn't exist! But if you have any suggestions on places we should look, I would welcome it! We are also doing more research on Roatan, Honduras, Bocas del Toro Panama, DR.... U.S. Virgin Islands have been ruled out due to cost of living :-)